Waters Towslee 1841-1845
Barnum Webster 1845-1847
Jacob McKinney 1847-1849
William H. Scott 1851-1852
Richard Winsor 1852
William H. Scott 1852-1853
Joseph White 1854
J.E. Henry 1855
Michael Laughlin 1856-1859
John Thielen 1859
Hugh McDermott 1860-1861
C.B. Westoon 1862
Christian Schend 1863
William Moeller 1864-1865
John Buddle 1866-1867
Henry Bostetter 1868
Joseph Hoffman 1869
John Buddle 1870
A.B. Truesdall 1871
John Tetard 1872-1875
Matt Stahl 1875-1876
James Irving 1877-1880
Joseph Newhouse 1881
John Harrington 1882-1884
Michael Harkins 1885
Michael Hoye 1887
Christian Schend 1888-1892
Michael Harkins 1892
C.F. Stenn 1892-1898
Marshall Barber 1899
Owen O'Hare 1899-1900
Joseph Newhouse 1901
H.H. Timme 1902
F.W. Reinold 1903-1908
Owen O'Hare 1908-1920
Thad W. Logan 1921-1928
John T. Sullivan 1928-1947
Stanley G. Haukedahl 1948-1963
J. Leo Buckmann 1963-1968
Robert L. Bosman 1968-1976
Daniel M. Cawley 1976-1981
Joseph H. Trotta 1981-1992
Gerald A. Schuetz 1992-1997
Daniel C. Wade 1997-2007
John W. Morrissey 2008-2016
Daniel G. Miskinis 2016-2021
Eric T. Larsen 2021-2022